Rising Incidents, Lax Oversight: Ohio Oil and Gas Incidents, Inspections, and Enforcement 2015–2025

Storage tanks at the Frost well, a Class II injection well site in Athens County, Ohio, standing in pooled water.

Rising Incidents, Lax Oversight

Ohio Oil and Gas Incidents, Inspections, and Enforcement, 2015–2025

Storage tanks at the Frost well, a Class II injection well site in Athens County, Ohio. Photo: Roxanne Groff, 2024.
Download the full report

Overview

Ohio’s oil and gas incident records document spills, leaks, equipment failures, and other potentially harmful events.1 These incident reports should help the public understand where these incidents occur, the risks to safety, health, and the environment, and how regulators and operators respond. But FracTracker Alliance’s analysis of Ohio Department of Natural Resources records from 2015 through 2025 found that, even as ODNR has improved some aspects of its data collection, major gaps remain. Incident classifications are often unclear, key details are buried in narrative descriptions, and records do not consistently show whether an event led to inspection, cleanup, enforcement, or corrective action. These gaps are particularly notable amid growing problems with oil and gas wastewater disposal, including releases and oil and gas wastewater migration associated with injection wells. However, one thing is clear: incidents are increasing in frequency on an annual basis. Without an understanding of the severity and complexity of these increasing oil and gas incidents, the public and policymakers may be lulled into a false sense of complacency and may be less likely to address serious problems until they threaten to become a crisis.

Key Findings

  • 2,529 oil and gas incidents were recorded in Ohio from 2015 through 2025.
  • Incidents are generally increasing, rising from 103 in 2015 to 268 in 2025, despite year-to-year variation.
  • Persistent problems with poor incident classification and fragmented descriptions make it difficult to determine what happened, the severity of the incident, and how it was resolved.
  • Our analysis shows that there is a lack of consistency in inspections, enforcement, and follow-up on the part of ODNR when wells have incidents or violations.
  • ODNR’s inspection capacity appears insufficient for consistent and meaningful oversight. Roughly 25 inspectors are responsible for Ohio’s 96,000 wells.

Our Previous Analysis

This analysis builds on FracTracker’s 2024-2025 series, Data Gaps: A Critical Examination of Oil and Gas Well Incidents in Ohio. That work began after the president of the Ohio Oil and Gas Association stated publicly in 2023 that Ohio had experienced only one or two oil and gas incidents affecting environmental health and public safety during the previous decade. The statement prompted longtime Ohio activist and founder of the Daily Accident Report, Jenny Morgan, to request incident records from the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) Division of Oil and Gas Resource Management (DOGRM).

The records2 told a very different story. After combining and cleaning ODNR’s annual spreadsheets, FracTracker identified approximately 2,000 incidents from 2015 through 2023. The analysis also found substantial problems with the data itself. Location information was frequently missing or inaccurate, incident classifications often failed to reflect the full nature of an event, and important details were buried in narrative descriptions. Roughly 100 records could not be included in the original map and analysis because their location information was too incomplete. Activist Jenny Morgan continued to dig into this important issue by creating the “Daily Accident Report,” a project documenting Jenny’s deep dives into specific incidents.

This updated analysis extends the dataset through 2025 and examines not only how incidents are recorded, but what the records show about the response that follows. ODNR has improved some aspects of its data collection, including location information, event types, and general consistency. But the expanded dataset exposes persistent problems with incident classification and raises broader questions about inspections, remediation, enforcement, and operator accountability. In many cases, the records still do not provide a clear path from the initial report of an incident to its eventual resolution.

What the Data Now Shows

Map of Ohio oil and gas incidents, 2015-2025. Open the full-screen map.

Number and Types of Incidents

One of the most notable trends in the data is an increase in incidents over the years of analysis. Since 2015, the number of incidents has generally gone up (Figure 1). Given the number of toxic substances associated with oil and gas wells, these incidents create the potential for communities and environments alike to be harmed.

Column chart of Ohio oil and gas incidents per year, 2015 to 2025, rising from 103 in 2015 to 268 in 2025, with a peak of 284 in 2024.
Figure 1. Oil and gas incidents by year, 2015-2025 (n = 2,529). Source: Ohio Department of Natural Resources incident records; data cleaned and analyzed by FracTracker.

Consistent with our original analysis, the majority of incidents remain as unspecified releases and discharges (Figure 2), followed by gas releases. Some examples of such incidents include:

ODNR incident recordNo. 2017025
CountyMonroe CountyIncident typeRelease/DischargeODNR classificationMajorLevel 2 of 5
DiscoveredJan 29, 2017ClosedFeb 16, 2017Days open18
OperatorJohn Burkhart Unregistered wellProduct releasedOil (Crude)Quantity reported40 BBLS
SummaryA release/discharge in Monroe County where a “property owner drained tank into Clear Fork Little Muskingum River on 1/28/17,” releasing 40 barrels of crude oil onto the land, constituting a “major” event classification.
ODNR incident recordNo. 2025080
CountyCarroll CountyIncident typeRelease/DischargeODNR classificationMinorLevel 4 of 5
DiscoveredMar 29, 2025Closed—Days openStill open
OperatorOWS Acquisitions Co LLCProduct releasedOil, Refined Sheen on Water FRQQuantity reported900
SummaryA “minor” release of 1,000 gallons of crude oil mischaracterized in the data as water. Wyatt #1, operated by OWS Acquisition, released crude oil into a ditch which then entered an unnamed tributary to Sandy Creek. OWS attempted to remediate the release by removing the crude oil and contaminated soil. This remediation and a subsequent repair of the well were allowed to occur while parts of production resumed, despite the noted impact to land and water in Carroll County.
ODNR incident recordNo. 201500102
CountyJefferson CountyIncident typeGas ReleaseODNR classificationModerateLevel 3 of 5
DiscoveredOct 28, 2015ClosedNov 16, 2015Days open19
OperatorHistoric WellProduct releasedNatural GasQuantity reportedUnable to estimate
SummaryDespite being categorized as a moderate gas release, this incident is described as “Report of gas odor” with no estimation of how much gas was released in Jefferson County.

Because of the dispersed, short-lived, and difficult-to-capture nature of gas releases, incidents involving the discharge of gas go unquantified in the data reporting, leaving little clarity about the volumes of gas released. Under Ohio’s incident-reporting requirements, a release of any amount of gas is reportable when it results from a blowout, an uncontrolled pop-off valve in an urban area, or otherwise threatens public safety. Authorized controlled flaring and certain other controlled releases are excluded from these reporting requirements. Liquid releases are more likely to have estimated volumes in reports, but those estimates are still often incomplete. Among the 2,373 records in which the “estimated quantity” field was populated, 797 records listed the quantity as “unknown” or “unable to quantify. Other records only provided poor estimates like “>32 barrels”. In addition, some records show a discrepancy between the amount released reported in the “estimated quantity released” field and the “brief description” field, suggesting that the reporting of incidents could still be improved. It is difficult to estimate how many of these records with discrepancies exist due to the sheer number of records. It is important for ODNR to improve reporting systems in order for the public to understand the full extent of these releases because oil and gas-related fluids, particularly oil and gas wastewater,3 could contain toxic PFAS and high levels of radioactivity.

Horizontal bar chart of incidents by type, 2015 to 2025; release/discharge (1,233) and gas release (615) lead.
Figure 2. Oil and Gas incidents by type, 2015-2025 (n = 2,529). Source: Ohio Department of Natural Resources incident records; data cleaned and analyzed by FracTracker.

Authorized Activity and Classification of Incidents

A large majority of incidents occur at “conventional” wells (Figure 3), a label that is likely to lead to confusion due to the lack of a definition of the word “conventional” in Ohio’s Oil and Gas code, and competing definitions in other prominent sources. In contrast, Ohio’s code defines a horizontal well as one drilled for oil or gas production in which the wellbore reaches a horizontal or near-horizontal position in the Point Pleasant, Utica, or Marcellus formation and the well is stimulated. “Stimulated” often means that the well has been hydraulically fractured. Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, is a well-stimulation process in which fluid is injected under pressure to fracture underground rock formations. “Horizontal,” “directional,” and “near horizontal,” describe the path of the wellbore. Horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing are commonly used together in shale development, and such wells are commonly called “unconventional.”

Taken together, this terminology might suggest that “conventional” wells are any wells that are not “unconventional” or any wells that do not combine horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing. However, Ohio’s Oil and Gas code does not make this distinction. The United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA), in its 2016 report on fracking and drinking water defined the difference between conventional and unconventional as related to the type of formation rather than to the type of technology used to extract oil or gas. “Conventional oil- and gas-bearing rock formations,” U.S.EPA wrote, “are often described as ‘permeable’ and tend to have many large, well-connected pore spaces that allow fluids to move within the rock formation. Unconventional oil- and gas-bearing rock formations do not exhibit these characteristics.” The U.S. EPA made clear that both conventional and unconventional wells could be fractured and that, in recent years, there had been increased production of oil and gas from unconventional formations (see page 1-3, including footnote 1, and page 3-1). Similarly, one of the world’s leading hydraulic fracturing companies, Schlumberger, notes in its Energy Glossary that the definition of “unconventional” has changed over time, but “[a]t present, the term is used in reference to oil and gas resources whose porosity, permeability, fluid trapping mechanism, or other characteristics differ from conventional sandstone and carbonate reservoirs. Coalbed methane, gas hydrates, shale gas, fractured reservoirs, and tight gas sands are considered unconventional resources.” Like U.S. EPA’s definition, Schlumberger’s characterization focuses on the nature of the formation, not the method of extraction.

On the other hand, the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) defines the difference between “conventional” and “unconventional” in part based on the technology used to produce oil and gas. “Conventional production generally means that crude oil and natural gas flow to and up a well under the natural pressure of the earth,” the EIA wrote. “Unconventional production requires techniques and technologies to increase or enable oil and natural gas production beyond what might occur using conventional production techniques.” Because Ohio law does not define “conventional,” it is unclear whether ODNR is applying any of the three definitions listed above or defines “conventional” and “unconventional” in a different way.

Conventional Does Not Equal Safer

As a result, ODNR’s use of the term “conventional well” in this dataset should not be read as a precise description of a well’s age, orientation, depth, or stimulation history. Some wells categorized as conventional may be vertical and older, and some may also have been hydraulically fractured, but are still distinct from horizontal wells. The “well phase” column within the data indicates that some incidents occurring on conventional wells happened during “completion/stimulation,” suggesting that conventional wells in this dataset may reference fracking activities. The dataset also includes “oil and gas production” as one of the categories of activity, or “authorized activity” as it is called in the data. It is unclear how that category differs from the conventional and horizontal well categories or whether it includes incidents associated with well stimulation. ODNR used the category from 2016 through 2022, but it does not appear in the more recent records.

Labeling oil and gas wells as “conventional,” without defining the term, may lead some people to inaccurately assume that incidents at these wells pose less of a risk to the public. This assumption may stem, in part, from the fact that most oil and gas production in Ohio and the U.S. now comes from unconventional wells, using the definitions listed above. And it is these unconventional operations that have received most of the attention in recent years regarding pollution impacts. But because Ohio does not define “conventional,” the label does not indicate whether an incident associated with it poses less risk.

A separate regulatory distinction may reinforce the perception of the relative safety of “conventional” wells. In 2016, U.S. EPA issued a rule prohibiting water from onshore unconventional oil and gas wells from being disposed of in Publicly Owned Treatment Works (POTWs). POTWs typically collect wastewater from homes and businesses and send it to sewage treatment plants. U.S. EPA defined unconventional oil and gas resources as “crude oil and natural gas produced by a well drilled into a shale and/or tight formation (including, but not limited to, shale gas, shale oil, tight gas, and tight oil).” Wastewater from conventional wells was not covered by the rule.

However, in U.S. EPA’s 2016 report on fracking and drinking water, the agency wrote that “[p]roduced water generated from unconventional reservoirs is reported to be similar to produced water from conventional reservoirs in terms of TDS [total dissolved solids], pH, alkalinity, oil and grease, TOC [total organic carbon], and other organics and inorganics.” Produced water, as U.S. EPA defined it in its 2016 report, is wastewater. Therefore, it is unclear whether wastewater from conventional wells is significantly different than wastewater from unconventional wells. And it is possible that incidents at either conventional or unconventional wells involving wastewater could pose pollution risks. These uncertainties and the lack of a definition for conventional wells in Ohio’s Oil and Gas code means that Ohioans should not assume that incidents at “conventional” wells are safer than those at other types of wells.

Horizontal bar chart of incidents by authorized activity; conventional wells account for 1,309 of 2,524 incidents.
Figure 3. Incidents by authorized activity, excluding five records with no authorized activity listed. 2015-2025 (n=2,524). Source: Ohio Department of Natural Resources incident records; data cleaned and analyzed by FracTracker.

In addition to qualifying incidents by the authorized activity at a given incident site, ODNR also uses an incident classification matrix to categorize the severity of reported incidents (Figure 4). The matrix considers both the reported consequences of an incident and the agency’s assessment of whether the release or hazard is contained or under control. Because those judgments may be made before the full extent of an incident is known, the classification can reflect the initial perception of control and impact rather than the event’s ultimate severity. An incident may therefore be classified as minor when it appears to have been contained quickly or to have caused limited harm, while incidents perceived as uncontrolled or more consequential receive a higher classification.

ClassificationIncident criteria
Information Only
Level 5 incident
Normal conditions. DOGRM involvement only. Controlled and stabilized in less than 4 hours. Follow-up by DOGRM within 24 to 48 hours. Little to no resource needs. Does not exceed reportable quantities with nominal public safety or environmental impact.
Minor
Level 4 incident
Normal conditions. May/may not involve other agencies. Controlled and stabilized in less than 4 hours. Limited deployment within 2 hours. Little to no resource needs. Exceeds reportable quantities with minimal public safety or environmental impact.
Moderate
Level 3 incident
Increased Readiness Conditions. One to three agencies involved due to regulatory authority. Controlled and stabilized in less than 12 hours. Immediate deployment with extended operational phase(s). Additional resources needed. Exceed reportable quantities with considerable public safety or environmental impact.
Major
Level 2 incident
Escalated Response Conditions. Multiple agency involvement and coordination. Uncontrolled impact will take 12 to 24 hours to contain hazard(s). Immediate deployment with extended operational phase(s). Additional resources needed. Exceeds reportable quantities with sizeable public safety or environmental impact.
Severe
Level 1 incident
Emergency Response Conditions. Multiple agency involvement and coordination. Uncontrolled impact will take 24 hours or more to contain hazard(s). Immediate deployment with extended operational phase(s). Additional resources needed. Exceeds reportable quantities with significant public safety or environmental impact.
Figure 4. The incident classification matrix for Ohio oil and gas incidents. 2025. Source: ODNR Emergency Operations & Response Master Incident Data Tracking (MIDT), Recreated by FracTracker Alliance.

Moderate, major, and severe incidents have seemingly decreased over time (Figure 5), but descriptions of minor incidents are not convincing as “minor”. Incident 201600072, which occurred in 2016, was classified as minor and described as “Static electricity from overhead power lines caused a conventional well’s tank to explode.” The explosion of the EnerVest-operated tank released 59 barrels4 (2,478 gallons) of crude oil and 5 barrels (210 gallons) of oil and gas wastewater. Because this event was classified as minor, it may indicate that there were few impacts to the environment, or that the incident was contained quickly. However, the records indicate this incident was open for four days, leading to questions about the accuracy of the classification. It is unclear if the incident was “open” due to prolonged discharge or if remediation and follow-up took multiple days, but more information is needed to determine if “minor” was an appropriate classification.

As concerning as the incident classification itself is, prior to the incident, the well had not been inspected for 12 years according to Ohio’s Oil and Gas Database, also referred to as RBDMS. After the explosion in 2016, the well was inspected in 2017, 2019, and twice in 2024, suggesting that inspections may increase after incidents, but are generally inconsistent. None of the following inspections made mention of the explosion. Records also indicate that in 2020, EnerVest sold the associated well to OWS Acquisitions, but this change in ownership did not prompt any additional inspections. While Ohio law does not appear to mandate inspections upon every ownership transfer, the absence of one was notable given the well’s incident history.

ODNR incident recordNo. 201600072
CountyColumbiana CountyIncident typeExplosionODNR classificationMinorLevel 4 of 5
DiscoveredApr 22, 2016ClosedApr 27, 2016Days open4
OperatorEnerVest Operating LLCProduct releasedOil (Crude)Quantity reported59 bbl, 5bbls brine

Incident 201600072 is not the only example of potential mischaracterizations of well incidents. Another “minor” incident is incident 2025018, which involved an unknown quantity of oil and gas wastewater released from a well while it was being plugged through an orphan well program. ODNR’s records state that the well had been “flowing overnight with no well control in place” and was located in a 100-year floodplain. Both the duration of the release and potential scale suggest this incident’s severity was misclassified by the agency’s own criteria, especially considering that in the “Estimated Quantity Released” field, the volume listed was “Brine >42 US Gal. in 24 hrs,” a reportable quantity if the oil and gas wastewater was released into the environment. Conflicting information within the data (e.g., both the note of an “unknown quantity” and “Brine >42 US Gal. in 24 hrs” within the same incident record) makes it difficult to understand how much was actually released and if the incident should be considered “minor”. Inspection reports show that after this incident, the well was not inspected until 9 months later, when the orphaned well restoration was complete, meaning the amount of oil and gas wastewater released may still be unknown. These two examples above are not outliers; other records in incident data follow similarly concerning patterns of mischaracterization.

Two-panel chart of incidents per year by classification: minor incidents ranged from 69 to 157 per year, while moderate, major, and severe incidents fell from 33 in 2015 to 6 or fewer per year since 2019.
Figure 5. Declines in moderate, major, and severe incidents, 2015-2025. Source: Ohio Department of Natural Resources incident records; data cleaned and analyzed by FracTracker.

Events by County

Given the pattern of mischaracterized incidents, it’s worth examining where incidents are concentrated. Stark and Noble counties have the highest counts of incidents, with each county recording about 130 incidents (Figure 6). These counties both have a moderately high number of wells, but according to FracTracker records, they do not have the largest number of total wells. Incidents in these two counties follow the general trend of the data; releases at conventional wells dominate the incidents within these counties.

Horizontal bar chart of the 25 Ohio counties with the most incidents; Stark (133) and Noble (129) lead.
Figure 6. Incidents by county, 2015-2025 (n=2,529). Source: Ohio Department of Natural Resources incident records; data cleaned and analyzed by FracTracker.

Incident Durations

Incident durations may also be cause for concern. In this analysis, FracTracker Alliance defines “duration” as the time, in days, between incident discovery date and closure date as noted in the records. According to the records, many incidents were “closed” or addressed within the same day (Figure 7). Closure is not defined in the Ohio Administrative Code that dictates emergency response and tracking, but likely refers to completing any follow-up to an incident, like field response, remediation, documentation, or another administrative milestone. Many of the incidents that were addressed within a day were incidents classified as less severe, that is, those classified as “information only,” “agency assist,” “agency referral,” and “minor” (Figure 8). However, despite many less severe incidents being closed within the same day, 486 incidents took over a month to close, and 249 records from as far back as 2018 remain open, or without a closure date today. These open records could be a reflection of the time it takes to fully remediate sites, a gap in documentation and data entry, or the Oil and Gas Management Division’s lax philosophy on addressing violations, where the “Division seeks to return the regulated community to compliance at the lowest level of enforcement possible”. Public confidence in ODNR’s response would be improved by enforcement that is clearly commensurate with the severity of the incident.

Column chart of days from discovery to closure: 1,007 incidents closed the same day, 486 took more than a month, and 249 remain open.
Figure 7. Duration of incidents before closure, 2015-2025 (n=2,529). Source: Ohio Department of Natural Resources incident records; data cleaned and analyzed by FracTracker.
Grouped column chart of average and median days to close by incident classification; major incidents averaged 629 days with a median of 66.5.
Figure 8. The average and median durations of closed/addressed incidents, 2015-2025 (n = 2,529). Source: Ohio Department of Natural Resources incident records; data cleaned and analyzed by FracTracker.

As with the previous FracTracker analysis on the topic, the “Brief Description” field continues to be the most comprehensive attribute in understanding incidents. The field often describes equipment failure found during routine inspections and maintenance, as well as landowner notification of leaks, spills, and odors. The field also sometimes details the inspector’s actions, follow-up, or communication around an incident. The “Brief Description” field also highlights shortcomings in the dataset’s other categories. It more frequently quantifies volumes of products released than the other data columns, and gives additional context that reveals discrepancies in incident classification.

Oil and Gas Wastewater Disposal in Injection Wells, Transportation, and Road Spreading

How injection wells work

The waste is not stored in an empty subterranean tank or cavern; it enters the pore spaces of permeable rock within the injection zone. Injected fluids move through pore spaces in the receiving formation. If a well is improperly constructed or operated, if natural fractures already exist, if a high volume of injected fluids creates fractures, if improperly plugged wells are present, or if there is no porous and permeable reservoir, trapping mechanism, or impermeable seal to prevent fluid flow, fluids can migrate outside the permitted injection zone.

A note on terms. This report uses “oil and gas wastewater” to describe the combination of naturally occurring toxic saltwater and flowback and chemicals incorporated to that water during the fracking process. Oil and gas wastewater is sometimes referred to as “brine” or “produced water,” in different contexts. These are distinct terms with distinct meanings but are often utilized interchangeably.

Incident reports related to transportation, disposal, storage, and spreading of oil and gas wastewater also raise significant tracking and response issues. Oil and gas companies inject oil and gas wastewater into underground formations through wells classified as Class II under the Safe Drinking Water Act’s Underground Injection Control program. FracTracker and Buckeye Environmental Network have previously collaborated to map some of Ohio’s more concerning injection wells.

Spills, leaks, and other releases of oil and gas wastewater can cause significant damage to the environment. In 2018, in Pickaway County, documented in incident 2018188, a routine inspection found a “brine kill area and leak of brine occurring from a pin hole size leak.” Further inspection notes that over 1 bbl (42 gallons) of oil and gas wastewater was released from the pinhole leak, raising questions about how long the leak continued before detection. Similarly, another incident states, “UIC inspector arrived on site for routine inspection and observed three separate kill area (sic) around the surface brine storage facility indicating a release of brine. Containment dike had approximately 10″ of brine and some oil in it.”

Issues involving oil and gas wastewater were not just limited to under-addressed leaks. They were also characterized by descriptions of oil and gas wastewater hauler accidents and potential unreported accidents. Examples include incident 2018220, which states “Tanker accident caused 20bbl of production brine released into a creek. OEPA DNR Wildlife informed. There was no recovery due to fast waters.” and incident 2018187, described as “Former employee reported underreporting of releases to the OneCall alleged release(s) have occurred in containment.” Numerous oil and gas wastewater truck rollovers and releases are described in the data, bringing up questions around the safety of transportation of oil and gas wastewater. Nine incidents directly reference “brine kill” or an area of vegetation that is or has been dying due to oil and gas wastewater releases to that area. The fact that such a phrase is well-documented in the records indicates the seriousness with which incidents involving oil and gas wastewater should be considered.

ODNR incident recordNo. 2021011
CountyWashington CountyIncident typeRelease/DischargeODNR classificationMinorLevel 4 of 5
DiscoveredJan 20, 2021ClosedApr 2, 2021Days open72
OperatorDeeprock Disposal Solutions LLCProduct releasedBrine >42 US Gal. in 24 hrsQuantity reported23 Barrels

Despite improvements in data collection, such as consistent field usage and better organization since our previous report, it continues to be difficult to properly evaluate the data. Incident 2021011 describes an issue with the Heinrich Unit #2 well owned by DeepRock Disposal Solutions LLC. The incident was described as “Visited site to determine if incident can be closed out. Operator hauled out the contaminated soil and filled in all the trenches. They also put down seed and straw.” There is no description of the incident that created the contaminated soil. It is unclear if this incident’s original description has been overwritten, and no other record in the incident data is attributed to this well’s name or API number, a unique numeric identifier assigned to each oil and gas well.

The only other incident associated with DeepRock within the incident data is incident 2024282, which could have created contaminated soil but is attributed to a different well. The description reads as follows:

ODNR incident recordNo. 2024282
CountyWashington CountyIncident typeRelease/DischargeODNR classificationMinorLevel 4 of 5
DiscoveredDec 22, 2024Closed—Days openStill open
OperatorDeeprock Disposal Solutions LLCProduct releasedBrine >42 US Gal. in 24 hrsQuantity reportedunk
ODNR brief description (as recorded)“Dave Casto (DeepRock) reported a brine release occurred at their site on December 22. 2024 at approximately 5:00PM. The brine release is reported to have consisted of between five and eight barrels that resulted from a defect in a check valve on the wellhead of the well named Helen F Hall (SWIW #7) 1-19. A portion of the brine was released outside of secondary containment and impacted land and a nearby intermittent drainage. Deeprock utilized absorbent material in an attempt to prevent migration of brine further into the environment on the evening of December 22, 2024. UIC Inspector Kyle Newbrough was notified of the release and visited on December 23, 2024. On site, Inspector Newbrough worked with Deeprock to construct containment and remediation measures. EOR Coordinator Nathan Lane visited the site to ensure the release was stabilized, leading edge controlled, and remediation is underway.”

Another incident involved DeepRock but was not associated with DeepRock in the incident data. In incident 2021015, oil and gas wastewater shot from a production well at 42 gallons a minute (Figure 9) in Noble County in 2021. The source of the oil and gas wastewater was nearby wells where DeepRock was injecting oil and gas wastewater, according to a later Chief’s Order by ODNR. However, the incident data assigns the incident to the well at which the blowout occurred, named Ohio Power Gant #17-69, operated by Genesis Resources LLC.

This assignment of the incident to Genesis Resources LLC, rather than DeepRock, is not just a difficulty for those exploring the data. While it is reasonable to tag the location of this incident as occurring at the Ohio Power Gant #17-69 well, initially attributing the cause of the incident solely to the operator Genesis Resources may not only make searching for more information on a highly publicized incident difficult, but also may have implications for ensuring proper enforcement and mitigation related to the incident. Prior to the incident, ODNR had ordered Ohio Power Gant #17-69 to be plugged, but Genesis Resources had not done so. DeepRock’s injection wells were suspended, but the state held Genesis Resources responsible for the cost of remediation, an issue that is now the subject of a lawsuit from Genesis Resources’ insurance agency. Additionally, since its suspension, DeepRock has been fighting to reopen the wells and has most recently appealed the Chief’s Order to remain shut down to the Ohio Oil and Gas Commission. Concerningly, the seat of this commission that represents the public is vacant during this appeals process.

ODNR photo of oil and gas wastewater spraying from the Ohio Power-Gant #17-69 well in Noble County, January 2021.
Figure 9. A photo of incident 2021015, 2021. Source: Public records request to ODNR for incident photo log for Ohio Power-Gant #17-69.

Enforcement

The records indicate a few channels through which regulators discover, or are notified of, incidents. Sometimes, inspectors identify incidents during routine inspections. Incidents have also been called in by well operators or emergency services near a given well. Many records indicate that landowners, not well operators, are the ones spotting leaks and flagging when remediation efforts were not completed successfully. Additionally, some incidents are reported through Ohio EPA’s emergency response program. Although Ohio EPA (OEPA) is not the primary regulator of the oil and gas industry, they do assist ODNR when pollutants leave a given well pad, enter waterways, or threaten public drinking water. This shared response can make it difficult to determine responsibility for the follow-up and long-term inter-agency oversight regarding incidents. OEPA notes that a significant portion of the incidents they respond to deal with releases of petroleum products. They also note that the responsible party for many incidents is the operator itself, who is also often responsible for the cost of clean-up. With only around 25 oil and gas inspectors in ODNR and roughly 15 coordinators for Ohio EPA’s Emergency Response program, efforts by the state regulatory agencies to prevent and remediate incidents may be limited in nature by logistical factors such as caseload and time spent with a given case.

An analysis conducted by FracTracker for this report found that the 25 inspectors at ODNR are responsible for roughly 96,000 active wells, not including wells that are plugged or abandoned. Using Ohio’s RBDMS system, FracTracker was able to access the duration of inspections and average the amount of time inspectors have spent on inspections in recent years. Reviewing only current inspectors leads us to conclude that it would require, on average, roughly 664 work days per inspector to review all the active wells in the state. This means that it would take inspectors in the state over two-and-a-half work years to return to a given well. While this average is helpful for understanding that ODNR inspectors are overall overburdened, some inspectors are especially overburdened. For example, one inspector is responsible for roughly 1,500 wells, all contained within Harrison County. Another inspector is responsible for all wells in 26 counties, which total around 24,000 wells. This roughly estimated inspector burden does not take into account the responsibility of ODNR inspectors to examine and regulate more inactive well types.

Unrealistic inspector workloads have practical consequences for how frequently wells are inspected and how problems are identified. Buckeye Environmental Network has documented many instances in which an inspection was both necessary and not completed. One such example is that of the Kris-Mar 1 oil and gas production well located in Washington County, in Marietta, Ohio. In 2019 and 2020, oil and gas wastewater was suspected to have migrated from a neighboring wastewater injection well and bubbled out of conventional production wells near Kris-Mar 1. Although ODNR had been notified of issues with neighboring production wells, it did not inspect Kris-Mar 1 until 2021, at which point the well had not been in production since 2018. The 2021 inspection cited a violation for failure to post notification, which is the required signage identifying the well name, operator, and emergency contact information, and gave the operator 10 days to remedy it. Nearly a year passed before the next inspection, which found the same posting violation still unresolved and noted “an old release in the area.” By the following inspection in 2023, the well was actively leaking and had destroyed surrounding vegetation, as documented in the inspection reports and in incident 2023100. Each of these earlier visits had been spent revisiting the same unaddressed violation, a pattern that continued to shape ODNR’s response after the fact. What followed the leak was a years-long process of compliance notices and requests to remove contaminated soil, with inspections becoming more frequent but the well still struggling to reach full compliance long after the leak was first observed. This means that inspectors had to spend a significant amount of time attempting to bring this well into compliance, visiting the site a total of 20 times between May 2023 and October 2025. This incident record has not yet been closed. Perhaps at least some of the pollution and the time-consuming regulatory efforts could have been avoided had ODNR’s inspector been able to inspect Kris-Mar 1 sooner and more regularly.

An additional question as to why this well was leaking also remains. Wells in this area have been suspected by oil and gas producers and advocates to be leaking due to nearby wastewater injection wells, including DeepRock’s American Growers #1 well, 1,120 feet away from the Kris-Mar 1 well. Cumulative subsurface pressure from injection wells receiving millions of gallons of oil and gas wastewater in Southeast Ohio is possibly resulting in migration of the waste fluids into these conventional wells, leading to increasing pressures at the conventional wells and releases into the environment, such as what has occurred at the Kris-Mar 1. At the time of writing this analysis, these suspicions were made more tangible after ODNR announced the voluntary cessation of operations for four injection wells in Washington County, Ohio. In recent years, disposal zones in Southeastern Ohio have produced “unprecedented migration of brine [wastewater],” according to ODNR. The ODNR should immediately investigate instances when there is suspected migration of oil and gas wastewater, rather than taking a “wait and see” approach.

Beyond the thousands of production wells in Ohio, ODNR has sited 232 active or permitted Class II Injection Wells throughout the state. A different set of four inspectors are responsible for the inspection of these wells. These inspectors not only have the major undertaking of being responsible for 50+ wastewater injection wells, but they also cover a vast geographical area. One inspector is reportedly responsible for counties including Holmes, Tuscarawas, Perry, and Washington, a non-contiguous area that spans over 2,000 square miles.

This high inspector burden, paired with the potential remediation costs or fines operators may incur for reporting incidents, means the onus of reporting is seemingly left to landowners and residents who may have oil and gas wells on and around their land. The option for citizens to report incidents they see is vital; citizen reporting means more eyes on the incidents and more trust between citizens and the regulators that serve them. However, the current reliance on citizen reporting undermines regulatory accountability, relieving operators of their fundamental obligation to ensure well safety.

ODNR’s website describes an escalatory approach for enforcement, ranging from informal to more formal measures, depending on the nature of violations. However, FracTracker separately requested records for “nonappealable Material and Substantial violations from 2000 to 2025,” that is, violations with formal enforceable action through Ohio’s oil and gas code. FracTracker Alliance undertook a small, separate analysis of these violation records since 20195, and found that very few violations have addressed incidents, spills, or pollution events. For example, the widely publicized 2021 DeepRock Disposal incident resulted in Chief’s Order 2023-02 suspending the wells of concern, but did not result in any additional fines, violations, or further enforcement action. As stated earlier in this report, DeepRock Disposal is currently attempting to reopen those injection wells that were problematic.

In a similar manner, a report conducted by Buckeye Environmental Network on the Redbird #4 wastewater injection well, whose oil and gas wastewater migration led to the flooding of 28 conventional production wells, documented another case of ODNR’s inability or unwillingness to pursue enforcement. Production well owners who noticed fluid in their wells contacted ODNR directly to report the incident. Inspectors, after waiting half a year and only after being prompted by a state representative-brokered meeting, discovered high pressures and oil and gas wastewater migration as far as five miles away from the wastewater injection well of concern. These concerns were not noted in the incident data, and did not result in a violation. Instead, Redbird Development LLC, the operator of Redbird #4, was allowed to submit voluntary changes to their operations and permits, plug only some of the geologic formation, and resume operations.

Rather than violations reflecting on-the-ground safety and pollution-related concerns and liabilities, violations are instead issued for administrative issues, like failing to report production amounts or failing to maintain liability insurance (Figure 10). Other Chiefs’ orders that appeared semi-regularly in the records were revocations of injection and plugging requests, but these records did not strongly indicate that any safety, health, or environmental incidents were considered in these plugging and revocation orders. When violations that could involve civil penalties are not pursued, ODNR forgoes potential revenue for Ohio and weakens financial deterrents against non-compliance that poses a risk to public health and the environment. While these plugging and revocation efforts are steps in the right direction, there is a need to better link incidents with accountability and enforcement.

Scanned 2019 ODNR Chief's Order, an example of a non-appealable material and substantial violation.
Figure 10. An example of a non-appealable material and substantial violation. 2019. Source: Public records request made to ODNR-DOGRM in 2025 by FracTracker.

Suggestions for Improvement of Incident Tracking and Enforcement

In order for the public to evaluate risks to their drinking water and health associated with oil and gas companies operating, or proposing to operate, in their communities, incident data must be more accessible. Accessible data allows residents, reporters, and regulators to quickly determine whether a company has a history of incidents or violations or if multiple violations have been issued regarding a particular type of well, such as wastewater injection wells. However, part of making data accessible includes having shared definitions of terms. If terms like “incident,” “conventional well,” and “closure date” were defined either in Ohio’s oil and gas code or within a separate data dictionary associated with the records, the public understanding of such events would be bolstered. Where Ohio’s definitions differ from definitions used in federal data or by other states, those differences should be made clear.

FracTracker commends ODNR for their improvements in data reporting, but there is still a distinct need for better protocols to address issues related to wells. As a starting point, Ohio Revised Code §1509.041 requires non-appealable material and substantial violations to be posted to ODNR’s website. To conduct this analysis, FracTracker Alliance had to submit a public records request to obtain this data, which did not appear on the dedicated webpage. At the time of finalizing this analysis, this information appears on the Orders by the Chief database, which aggregates all legal directives related to oil and gas in Ohio. The Chief’s Orders are not consistently displayed on the website, leading to gaps in regulatory transparency. In addition, records are only available starting in July of 2010. There is a need for distinction between these databases and webpages, consistent updates, and better transparency within these information systems. Additionally, ODNR’s RBDMS database, which contains oil and gas inspections by well in addition to well records on completion, permits, and production, while information-rich, is inaccessible to a majority of residents. It could be made more accessible to the public by having more frequent and timely updates and by linking it to accessible training on how to query and utilize the database. The database currently exists on Microsoft Access, which can be inaccessible due to its difficulty to use and paid licensing requirements. By moving the database to a different format, like SQLite, the public may have an easier time exploring the information available. This shift would also benefit ODNR; Microsoft Access has a 2-gigabyte size limit that the RBDMS system has outgrown, splitting the well history and well tables across two files the state tracks and undermining the purpose of a relational database.

Ohio law authorizes civil penalties for oil and gas violations, but ODNR’s DOGRM does not appear to have authority to impose those penalties directly through an administrative order. Instead, the division chief must request that the Ohio attorney general bring a civil action to recover penalties under Ohio Revised Code §1509.33. ODNR can independently use other enforcement tools, including compliance orders, permit suspensions, bond forfeiture, and referrals for injunctive relief. However, the absence of fines may make such notices, particularly the compliance orders, easy to disregard. Relatedly, in 2015, following a citizen’s petition filed by Buckeye Environmental Network and others, the U.S. EPA evaluated ODNR’s Underground Injection Control program. U.S. EPA said that they recommend implementing fines to hold bad actors accountable. To date, we are not aware of any instances of ODNR using the attorney general’s office to issue fines for companies violating Ohio’s injection well laws. This approach to enforcement may have allowed companies to avoid meaningful consequences for repeated violations.

FracTracker Alliance and Buckeye Environmental Network also recommend a smaller inspector-to-well ratio, so that wells are inspected with the regularity required to avoid oil and gas pollution events, leaks, and spills, otherwise referred to as “incidents”. Because of the length of time it takes for ODNR to inspect and address potential incidents and violations, more formal enforcement actions should be taken for long-running violations and incidents. In practice, these actions could include fines for any long-standing or unremediated violation or incident. In addition, violations or contamination events should result in an immediate stop-work order until the issue is remediated. This action would once again be bolstered by treatment of incidents as material and substantial violations, addressed with formal enforceable action through Ohio’s oil and gas code, rather than as separate tracking and enforcement measures.


Appendix A. Oil and Gas Wastewater Glossary

“Brine,” “Produced Water,” and “Oil and Gas Wastewater” are often used interchangeably, but come from different industry, legal, and regulatory contexts. To clarify, in this report we use “oil and gas wastewater” to encapsulate many terms that reference the often salty water that is brought above ground during extraction activities. This wastewater may be reused or injected back underground.

“Produced water” may be the term that most closely matches our definition of “oil and gas wastewater” but is not used by Ohio regulators or legislators, and may connote a substance that is not harmful. By using “oil and gas wastewater,” we aim to highlight the potential dangers of the fluids involved in extraction.

TermSource / used byMeaning
BrineOhio’s Oil and Gas Code Definitions (1509.01-U)“All saline geological formation water resulting from, obtained from, or produced in connection with exploration, drilling, well stimulation, production of oil or gas, or plugging of a well.”
Produced WaterU.S. EPA“The fluid brought up from the hydrocarbon-bearing strata during the extraction of oil and gas, and includes, where present, formation water, injection water, and any chemicals added downhole or during the oil/water separation process.” Produced water is often re-used in oil and gas extraction via practices like Enhanced Oil Recovery.
Oil and Gas WastewaterU.S. EPA, Sierra Club, FracTracker Alliance, and Buckeye Environmental NetworkNaturally occurring saltwater that is already toxic, combined with flowback (fluids, sands, or hydrocarbons that return to the surface during fracking) and chemicals added during the extraction process. This wastewater may or may not be reused for further extraction, or injected underground.

Sources and More Information

FracTracker’s work on this analysis

Other sources

FracTracker Alliance. (n.d.). National Oil & Gas Well inventory portal. FracTracker Wells Portal. https://wells.fractracker.org/

Glabicki, Q. (2026, July 29). In Ohio, toxic wastewater is bubbling up out of the ground – The New York Times. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/29/climate/ohio-fracking-water-injection-wells.html

How much shale (tight) oil is produced in the United States? – frequently asked questions (FAQs) – U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA). (n.d.). https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=847&t=6

Injection Wells | Ohio Department of Natural Resources. Ohio Department of Natural Resources. (n.d.). https://ohiodnr.gov/business-and-industry/energy-resources/injection-wells

Kington, D. (2026, February 19.). Lawsuit: Fracking waste company should pay for 2021 disaster. Athens County Independent. https://athensindependent.com/deeprock-fracking-waste-lawsuit-2/

Kington, D. (2026, September 17). Operator fights to reopen Injection Wells linked to disaster. Athens County Independent. https://athensindependent.com/deeprock-appeal-noble-county-injection-wells/

Klenke, G. (2025, January). Data gaps: A critical examination of oil and gas well incidents in Ohio. FracTracker Alliance. https://www.fractracker.org/2025/01/data-gaps-a-critical-examination-of-oil-and-gas-well-incidents-in-ohio/

Morgan, J. (n.d.). The Daily Accident Report-Ohio Oil & Gas. Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61560490386193&fbclid=IwY2xjawUjtrJleHRuA2FlbQIxMABwZG9mAWJyaWQRMUNaUWh1b0hFandWVlNEOHVzcnRjBmFwcF9pZBAyMjIwMzkxNzg4MjAwODkyAAEeOfiF2H8RYrQ1MtE_3pdzxPiGHKfT7UsUcSbvUiddUnG1hNTn2Qb7zU5wvFw_aem_xrdKMrnCWo8oqLGw-74_DQ

Nobel, J. (2025, March 24). Radioactive Shadow Workers | The treatment of oil and gas field waste is a dirty industry’s dirtiest secret. Sierra Club. https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/2025-1-spring/feature/radioactive-oil-gas-shadow-workers

Ohio Department of Natural Resources. (2018, September 27). Incident guide (Reprint). https://dam.assets.ohio.gov/image/upload/ohiodnr.gov/documents/oil-gas/resources/IncidentGuide_RePrint%20FINAL%209272018.pdf

Ohio Department of Natural Resources – Division of Oil and Gas Resources Management. (2026, January 13). Risk Based Data Management System (RBDMS) inspection records for Kris Mar #1 (API Well No. 341672508400). State of Ohio. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1p2WERwDPnHJIwGKE6pU_0s9YtVHa9Ulb/view?usp=drive_link

Ohio Department of Natural Resources – Division of Oil and Gas Resources Management. (2026, July 20). CSI BIA package for “No change” filing for oil and gas definitions, permits, simultaneous operations, prevention of pollution and contamination, and safety rules. https://dam.assets.ohio.gov/image/upload/ohiodnr.gov/documents/oil-gas/rules/CSI_BIA_Package.pdf

Ohio Department of Natural Resources, Division of Oil and Gas Resources Management. (2024, October 28). Chief’s Order No. 2024-470: Arrowhead Road Services No. 1 (SWIW #27) Well API #34-167-2-9771-0000. State of Ohio. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1me8JvFj-pwTRJu7egzvhxtsY0I6QnjVv/view

Ohio Department of Natural Resources – Division of Oil & Gas Resources Management. (2021, January 25). Incident photograph log: Ohio Power-Gant #17-69 follow-up (Incident No. 2021015, API Well No. 34121232160000). https://drive.google.com/file/d/1j_S8vXkZGLOko5WzzrAkVzGgwCK49QMX/view

Ohio Department of Natural Resources — Division of Oil and Gas. Oil & Gas Commission.(n.d.). https://ohiodnr.gov/business-and-industry/municipalities-and-public-entities/commissions-and-councils/oil-gas-commission

Ohio Department of Natural Resources. (n.d.). Oil & Gas Inspections and enforcement. Resources. https://ohiodnr.gov/business-and-industry/energy-resources/required-inspections-and-enforcement/oil-gas-inspections-enforcement

Ohio Department of Natural Resources. (n.d.). Oil & Gas Well database. https://ohiodnr.gov/business-and-industry/energy-resources/well-information/featured-content-3

Ohio Department of Natural Resources. (n.d.). Public Database of Non-Appealable orders for Violations. https://ohiodnr.gov/rules-and-regulations/rules-and-regulations-by-division/oil-and-gas/public-database-of-non-appealable-orders-for-violations

Ohio Environmental Protection Agency. (n.d.). Emergency response. https://epa.ohio.gov/divisions-and-offices/emergency-response

Oil and Gas Production in Ohio. Ohio Legislative Service Commission. (2024, October). https://www.lsc.ohio.gov/assets/organizations/legislative-service-commission/files/oil-and-gas-production-in-ohio-october-2024.pdf

Orders by the Chief. Ohio Department of Natural Resources — Division of Oil and Gas. (n.d.). https://ohiodnr.gov/wps/portal/gov/odnr/discover-and-learn/safety-conservation/about-ODNR/oil-gas/oil-gas-resources

Physicians for Social Responsibility. (2022, September). Fracking with forever chemicals in Ohio. https://psr.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/fracking-with-forever-chemicals-in-ohio.pdf

Physicians for Social Responsibility. (2023, October). Compendium of scientific, medical, and media findings demonstrating risks and harms of fracking (9th ed.). https://psr.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/fracking-compendium-9.pdf

Ramsay, V. (2025, November 26). A decade of danger: Why ODNR is allowing Deeprock to restart suspended injection wells near Washington County water sources?. Buckeye Environmental Network. https://benohio.org/a-decade-of-danger-why-odnr-is-allowing-deeprock-to-restart-suspended-injection-wells-near-washington-county-water-sources/

Ramsay, V. (2026, July 14). Sixteen months of organizing. Four Wells shut down. Buckeye Environmental Network. https://benohio.org/sixteen-months-of-organizing-four-wells-shut-down/

Reed, B. (2026, July 2). Ohio Department of Natural Resources investigates leaking injection well, six years later the problem has gotten worse. Buckeye Environmental Network. https://benohio.org/ohio-department-of-natural-resources-investigates-leaking-injection-well-six-years-later-the-problem-has-gotten-worse/

Schlumberger. (n.d.). Unconventional resource. Energy Glossary. https://glossary.slb.com/en/terms/u/unconventional_resource

Section 1509.01: Division of oil and gas resources management – oil and gas definitions. Section 1509.01 – Ohio Revised Code | Ohio Laws. (n.d.). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-1509.01

Section 1509.041: Database listing final nonappealable orders issued for violations to be accessible to public. Section 1509.041 – Ohio Revised Code | Ohio Laws. (n.d.). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-1509.041

Section 1509.33: Civil penalties. Section 1509.33 – Ohio Revised Code | Ohio Laws. (n.d.). https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-1509.33

State of Ohio. (n.d.). Rule 1501:9-8-01: Definitions. Rule 1501:9-8-01 – Ohio Administrative Code | Ohio Laws. https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-administrative-code/rule-1501:9-8-01

U.S. energy information administration (EIA). (n.d.). U.S. shale natural gas production has declined so far in 2024. Today in Energy. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=63506

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (n.d.-c). Oil and Gas Extraction Effluent Guidelines. https://www.epa.gov/eg/oil-and-gas-extraction-effluent-guidelines

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (n.d.-c). Unconventional Oil and Gas Extraction Effluent Guidelines. https://www.epa.gov/eg/unconventional-oil-and-gas-extraction-effluent-guidelines

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region 5. (2015, September 8). Safe Drinking Water Act underground injection control program periodic program review: Ohio Class II (Final Report). https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ykPsxGbcD77zYM4THg-XhcP39awiRcEv/view

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2016) Hydraulic Fracturing for Oil and Gas: Impacts from the Hydraulic Fracturing Water Cycle on Drinking Water Resources in the United States (Final Report). U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, EPA/600/R-16/236F. https://cfpub.epa.gov/ncea/hfstudy/recordisplay.cfm?deid=332990

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2016, June 28). Effluent limitations guidelines and standards for the oil and gas extraction point source category. Federal Register. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2016/06/28/2016-14901/effluent-limitations-guidelines-and-standards-for-the-oil-and-gas-extraction-point-source-category

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2020, May). Summary of input on oil and gas extraction wastewater management practices under the Clean Water Act. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC, EPA-821-S19-001. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2020-05/documents/oil-gas-final-report-2020.pdf

Washington County produced water investigation. Ohio Department of Natural Resources — Division of Oil and Gas. (n.d.-b). https://ohiodnr.gov/discover-and-learn/safety-conservation/about-ODNR/oil-gas/oil-gas-resources/washington-county-investigation

WOSU Public Media. (2023, September 20). The state of fracking in Ohio [Radio broadcast]. In All sides with Anna Staver. https://www.wosu.org/show/all-sides-with-ann-fisher/2023-09-20/the-state-of-fracking-in-ohio

Zuckerman, J. (2024, May). Fracking waste wells owned by an Ohio senator are leaking. The state paid $1.3 million to clean it up. Cleveland.com. https://www.cleveland.com/open/2024/05/fracking-waste-wells-owned-by-an-ohio-senator-are-leaking-the-state-paid-13-million-to-clean-it-up.html

Notes

  1. The term “incident” is undefined by the Ohio Department of Natural Resources and Ohio Oil and Gas Code, but used throughout this report to reflect the records request and associated responsive data. ↩
  2. Data for this analysis was requested and received in three tranches. The first set of data requested, which included incidents from 2014 through early September of 2023 was requested by Jenny Morgan and received in early 2024. The second set of data requested included records from the last part of 2023 through April of 2025, and was requested by Jenny in January of 2025 and received in May of 2025. The final data set included all of 2025 records, and was requested by FracTracker in February of 2026 and received in March of 2026. ↩
  3. This report uses “oil and gas wastewater” to describe the combination of naturally occurring toxic saltwater and flowback and chemicals incorporated to that water during the fracking process. Oil and gas wastewater is sometimes referred to as “brine” or “produced water,” in different contexts. These are distinct terms with distinct meanings but are often utilized interchangeably. For a more extensive description of these terms, see Appendix A. ↩
  4. Barrels is abbreviated as “bbls” in the records ↩
  5. While FracTracker received all Chief’s orders records from 2000-2025, Chief’s orders records from before 2019 were not systematically reviewed for the small, separate analysis and may be reviewed for future work. ↩

Acknowledgments: Special thanks to Anton Krieger, Becca Pollard, Roxanne Groff, and Bev Reed of Buckeye Environmental Network, whose review, on-the-ground knowledge of Ohio’s injection wells, and photographs shaped this report.

Stay informedFracTracker Newsletter
Support our work

FracTracker Alliance helps communicate the risks of oil and gas and petrochemical development to advance just energy alternatives that protect public health, natural resources, and the climate.

By contributing to FracTracker, you are helping to make tangible changes, such as decreasing the number of oil and gas wells in the US, protecting the public from toxic and radioactive chemicals, and stopping petrochemical expansion into vulnerable communities.

Your donations help fund the sourcing and analysis of new data so that we can keep you informed and continually update our resources.

Please donate to FracTracker today as a way to advocate for clean water, clean air, and healthy communities.

Donate now
Drilling rig on a CNX (Consol Energy) fracking pad beyond a cattle pasture in Noble County, Ohio.

CNX’s Expanded Radiation Monitoring and Disclosure Fall Short

Drilling rig on a CNX (Consol Energy) fracking pad beyond a cattle pasture in Noble County, Ohio.

CNX’s Expanded Radiation Monitoring and Disclosure Fall Short

Ted Auch, 2017. Courtesy of FracTracker Alliance.

Download this press release

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

September 18, 2026

Contact: Shannon Smith, FracTracker Alliance, smith@fractracker.org, (814) 449–0659

CNX’s Expanded Radiation Monitoring and Disclosure Fall Short

FracTracker calls for comprehensive radiation testing and enforceable public reporting requirements across Pennsylvania’s oil and gas industry

PITTSBURGH, PA— Since CNX and Gov. Josh Shapiro launched their “Radical Transparency” partnership in 2023, FracTracker Alliance has repeatedly challenged its broad safety claims and reliance on voluntary company disclosure. CNX’s newly announced radiation monitoring and disclosure program raises the same concerns: limited monitoring cannot establish safety, and voluntary commitments cannot replace enforceable requirements. 

FracTracker Alliance supports comprehensive monitoring of radioactive materials in oil and gas waste. CNX’s announcement includes third-party collection of ambient gamma data and public disclosure of radiation surveys of waste leaving its sites. However, ambient gamma monitoring alone cannot identify or characterize the full range of radioactive contaminants or potential exposure pathways, and CNX’s own 2024 Comprehensive Radiation Protection Plan describes a broader suite of radiation-protection measures.

In its own February 2024 Comprehensive Radiation Protection Plan, analyzed in FracTracker’s Not-So-Radical Transparency report, CNX identified “drill cuttings, production water, flow-back solids/sludge, and pipe scale” as potential sources of radioactive material. CNX’s 2024 plan also notes the relevance of surveys of alpha and beta radiation, radon monitoring, airborne radioactive-particle sampling, and laboratory analysis of water and solid waste. Radical transparency entails a clearer explanation of why this “expanded” radiation monitoring falls short of the more comprehensive monitoring described in the 2024 plan. 

Equally concerning is the continued reliance on voluntary company commitments for radiation monitoring and disclosure, rather than enforceable requirements that apply consistently across Pennsylvania’s oil and gas industry. This leaves the company itself with substantial control over what gets measured and ultimately is made public. The limitations of voluntary industry disclosure are illustrated by the controversy around CNX’s water-testing program at its NV110 well site. A 2023 agreement said post-drilling water results would be made public when participating landowners approved their release, yet the site was later archived before all opted-in results were published. CNX subsequently said those results were not posted because the pre-drill samples preceded the Radical Transparency program and did not provide the baseline it wanted for comparison. The Center for Coalfield Justice notes this appears nowhere in the signed forms, calling it “changing the rules in the middle of the game.” Whatever the explanation, the episode demonstrates the problem with making public-health information dependent on a company’s voluntary disclosure program rather than a clear, enforceable disclosure requirement.

FracTracker’s recent report on Pennsylvania’s fracking waste highlights radioactive hazards and gaps in existing waste disclosure. Pennsylvania operators are required to submit Form 26R reports describing residual waste streams, including periodic chemical analyses. A collaborative Right-to-Know effort by Earthjustice, Ohio Valley Allies, WildEarth Guardians, and FracTracker obtained roughly 400,000 pages of previously difficult-to-access records. FracTracker’s analysis found chemical tests documenting very high concentrations of radioactive and other hazardous contaminants in some Pennsylvania oil and gas wastes. One wastewater sample from a Chesapeake-operated well pad in Bradford County contained a combined 9,890 picocuries per liter of radium-226 and radium-228—nearly 2,000 times EPA’s drinking-water limit. Measurements of external gamma radiation can provide useful information, but they are not a replacement for laboratory testing that identifies which radionuclides are present and at what concentrations.

In the past, CNX has stirred controversy by using the Radical Transparency program to claim that unconventional natural gas development is “safe and inherently good for the communities” it operates in. These claims, which have been publicly challenged by scientists, fly in the face of a robust scientific literature that documents clear associations between unconventional oil and gas development and adverse health outcomes. By introducing this narrow radiation monitoring program, CNX is not presenting the comprehensive evidence that would be required to fully assess the risks that radioactivity poses to public health. Such a narrow presentation of data and dismissal of a substantial body of scientific evidence documenting associations between unconventional oil and gas development and adverse health outcomes is neither radical nor transparent. FracTracker calls for comprehensive, enforceable radiation testing and disclosure requirements across Pennsylvania’s oil and gas industry, including alpha and beta testing of surface contamination, radon monitoring, and laboratory measurement of radioactive contaminants in liquid and solid waste. Such an effort should be led by the agencies responsible for protecting the health of Pennsylvanians. 

“We’ve been calling attention to gaps in monitoring for years, so yes, collecting more data is a good thing,” said Shannon Smith, Executive Director of FracTracker Alliance. “But CNX monitoring itself does not answer the larger public health questions, and it certainly does not make the company the authority on whether its operations are safe. Governor Shapiro should be investing in independent public health research and enforceable oversight instead of relying on a fracking company to monitor itself and then use its own data to make sweeping claims about public safety.”


###


FracTracker Alliance is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that maps, analyzes, and communicates the risks of oil, gas, and petrochemical development. To learn more, visit fractracker.org or connect with us @FracTracker.

Aerial view of a lined water impoundment and two storage tanks at a Seneca Resources site in Clearfield County, Pennsylvania, surrounded by autumn forest.

Tracking Pennsylvania’s Oil and Gas Waste in 2025

Overview

  • Pennsylvania’s oil and gas wells reported generating 72.6 million barrels of liquid waste and over 825,000 tons of solid waste in 2025, with unconventional wells, which comprise less than 15% of the state’s inventory, accounting for 98.6% of liquids and 99.8% of solids.
  • Nearly 50,000 conventional wells reported production but no waste at all, raising significant concerns about Oil and Gas operators exploiting gaps in the DEP’s reporting requirements. 
  • FracTracker and its partners worked together to obtain and analyze approximately 400,000 pages of required chemical-disclosure records, documenting high concentrations of radioactive and other hazardous contaminants in some Pennsylvania oil and gas waste.
  • Much of the reported “disposal” is really transfer. Waste ends up in processing facilities, temporary storage, and landfills that leach, leaving the public to grapple with the burden of living near toxic, often radioactive, waste long after the state stops tracking it. 

Introduction: The Price of Production

Pennsylvania produced over 7.8 trillion cubic feet of gas in 2025, a vast sum that is roughly equal to 16% of U.S. production and more than 5% of global production.   

Along with production comes enormous quantities of waste – over 825,000 tons of solid waste and 72.6 million barrels (3 billion gallons) of liquids that need to be disposed of, according to the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection’s waste data.  As a point of comparison, the solid waste reported by oil and gas operators in Pennsylvania in 2025 alone weighs more than 2.2 Empire State Buildings.  To get a sense of the volume of liquid waste, take a trip to Niagara Falls on a typical day, watching 757,500 gallons of water go over the falls every second, or take the boat ride for a more immersive experience.  After watching for 67 minutes, you’ll see the equivalent amount of water as the waste fluids that were generated last year by Pennsylvania O&G wells.

Pennsylvania Oil and Gas Waste in 2025. Open the full map.

The vast amount of O&G waste that comes with this scale of production is an enormous management problem in Pennsylvania, and beyond.

Where that waste ends up matters for workers, nearby communities and the environment. Oil and gas wastes can contain high concentrations of salts, hydrocarbons, metals, naturally occurring radioactive materials and other contaminants. Workers who handle, transport, process or dispose of these wastes may be exposed to hazardous chemicals, gases or radioactive materials, while spills, leaks or improper treatment and disposal can contaminate soil, groundwater and surface water and create risks for ecosystems and public health. Accurate waste reporting is therefore a basic safeguard: regulators, workers and the public need to know how much waste is being generated, what it contains, where it is going and how it is being managed in order to identify potential exposures, enforce waste-management requirements and understand which communities and facilities are bearing the burden of the industry’s waste.

In this article, we will take a closer look at some details of this process, including the different categories of waste, differences between waste streams from conventional and unconventional wells, a de facto waste reporting loophole for conventional operators, brine spreading, where the waste goes, and some example reports that include detailed chemical analyses revealing the high toxicity of liquid and solid waste.

Defining the Waste: Solids vs. Liquids

In the introduction, we discussed the two units that O&G waste is reported on in Pennsylvania – solid and liquid.  This is a useful shorthand to encompass the waste stream, as there are 18 different categories of waste type that appear on DEP’s waste reports. 

Waste TypeResidual Waste Code (RWC) DescriptionBarrelsPct. of Liquid WasteTonsPct. of Solid Waste
Basic Sediment (in Barrels) RWC 807Sediment from Production Storage – sediment from storage of marketable oil and gas product. Does not include sediment from oil and gas-related wastewater storage.1,3860.00%
Drill Cuttings (in Tons) RWC 810Drill Cuttings – oil and gas drill cuttings. [Rock encountered by the drill bit during boring]706,64985.63%
Drilling Fluid Waste (in Barrels) RWC 803Drilling Fluid Waste – oil and gas drilling mud, other drilling fluids other than fracturing fluid and spent lubricant. [Reported in barrels]272,4180.38%
Drilling Fluid Waste (in Tons) RWC 803Drilling Fluid Waste – oil and gas drilling mud, other drilling fluids other than fracturing fluid and spent lubricant. [Reported in tons]4,5070.55%
Filter Socks (in Tons) RWC 812Filter Socks – Filters, filter socks and other media used to filter any oil and gas-related wastewater. Does not include filter socks mixed with RWC 804 for disposal purposes. Except where filter socks are mixed with RWC 804 and coded as RWC 804, mixed loads of RWC 812 with other waste for disposal purposes, such as drill cuttings, will be coded as RWC 812.690.01%
Other Oil & Gas Wastes (in Barrels) RWC 899Other Oil and Gas Wastes – all remaining oil and gas wastes other than those already covered under existing RWCs. Includes containment water. Does not include rainwater that is collected in a containment area that has not been mixed with residual waste. [Reported in barrels]1,862,5092.56%
Other Oil & Gas Wastes (in Tons) RWC 899Other Oil and Gas Wastes – all remaining oil and gas wastes other than those already covered under existing RWCs. Includes containment water. Does not include rainwater that is collected in a containment area that has not been mixed with residual waste. [Reported in tons]14,7971.79%
Produced Fluid (in Barrels) RWC 802Produced Fluid – includes flow-back, brine and any other formation fluids recovered from the wellbore. Flow-back is defined as fracturing/stimulation fluids, including any colloidal and suspended solids within the fluid, recovered from the wellbore after injection into the wellbore. [Reported in barrels]70,294,32796.80%
Produced Fluid (in Tons) RWC 802Produced Fluid – includes flow-back, brine and any other formation fluids recovered from the wellbore. Flow-back is defined as fracturing/stimulation fluids, including any colloidal and suspended solids within the fluid, recovered from the wellbore after injection into the wellbore. [Reported in tons]54,6326.62%
Servicing Fluid (in Barrels) RWC 808Servicing Fluid – oil and gas production well maintenance/work over fluids, oil/water-based mud and foam and well cellar cleanout waste after drilling operations have been completed. Does not include well cellar cleanout waste covered under existing RWCs, well cellar fluids that are recycled/reused, or rainwater that is collected in a well cellar that has not been mixed with a residual waste. [Reported in barrels]129,0080.18%
Servicing Fluid (in Tons) RWC 808Servicing Fluid – oil and gas production well maintenance/work over fluids, oil/water-based mud and foam and well cellar cleanout waste after drilling operations have been completed. Does not include well cellar cleanout waste covered under existing RWCs, well cellar fluids that are recycled/reused, or rainwater that is collected in a well cellar that has not been mixed with a residual waste. [Reported in tons]1,7830.22%
Soil Contaminated by Oil & Gas Related Spills (in Barrels) RWC 811Soil Contaminated by Oil and Gas-related Spills – soil contaminated by spills of RWCs 802, 803, 805, 807, 808, 809 and 810. Soil contaminated by spills of RWC 804 will be coded using RWC 804. Soil contaminated by spills of RWC 812 will be coded using RWC 812. [Reported in barrels]20.00%
Soil Contaminated by Oil & Gas Related Spills (in Tons) RWC 811Soil Contaminated by Oil and Gas-related Spills – soil contaminated by spills of RWCs 802, 803, 805, 807, 808, 809 and 810. Soil contaminated by spills of RWC 804 will be coded using RWC 804. Soil contaminated by spills of RWC 812 will be coded using RWC 812. [Reported in tons]20,4402.48%
Synthetic Liner Materials (in Tons) RWC 806Synthetic Liner Materials – includes well site liners, liners used in pits or other approved storage structures, freshwater impoundments, centralized impoundments, or used in conjunction with primary containers.6,4860.79%
Unused Fracturing Fluid Waste (in Barrels) RWC 805Unused Fracturing Fluid Waste – oil and gas fracturing/stimulation fluid waste and fracturing sand waste that has not been injected into a wellbore.40,6310.06%
Unused Fracturing Fluid Waste (in Tons) RWC 805Unused Fracturing Fluid Waste – oil and gas fracturing/stimulation fluid waste and fracturing sand waste that has not been injected into a wellbore.2240.03%
Waste Water Treatment Sludge (in Barrels) RWC 804Wastewater Treatment Sludge – sludge and solids generated during the processing of any oil and gas-related wastewater including any sediment generated during storage of oil and gas-related wastewater. Mixed loads of wastewater treatment sludge with other waste for disposal purposes, such as filter socks (RWC 812), will be coded as RWC 804. [Reported in barrels]15,0860.02%
Waste Water Treatment Sludge (in Tons) RWC 804Wastewater Treatment Sludge – sludge and solids generated during the processing of any oil and gas-related wastewater including any sediment generated during storage of oil and gas-related wastewater. Mixed loads of wastewater treatment sludge with other waste for disposal purposes, such as filter socks (RWC 812), will be coded as RWC 804. [Reported in tons]15,6231.89%
Total Result72,615,367100.00%825,209100.00%

Table 1: O&G waste by type in 2025. Waste data was downloaded from Pennsylvania DEP on June 16, 2026. Waste type descriptions from Pennsylvania DEP, with FracTracker comments in square brackets.

The 70,294,327 barrels of produced fluids represents 96.8% of the volume of all of the liquid waste reported by Pennsylvania operators.  For solids, drill cuttings accounted for 85.6% of the mass, weighing in at 706,649 tons.   Both waste types carry a heavy contaminant load, mostly from naturally occurring but toxic components that had previously been locked away deep in the earth’s crust.

DEP has changed how it classifies these categories of oil and gas waste numerous times in recent years.  Because of these frequent changes in DEP classifications, any analysis of waste types from year to year should be conducted with significant attention to these details.  In the 2018 rules, for example, produced fluids were categorized as Residual Waste Code (RWC) 802, while fracturing fluid waste, including the fluid that comes up in the first 30 days of operation that has a higher proportion of injected chemicals (frequently called flowback fluid) was classified as RWC 805. See pages 22-23 of the 2018 reporting manual for more details.  With the 2022 rules, both waste types are now reported together under RWC 802.  Several changes were made to the list of RWC codes in 2016, as well.  

In comparison, aggregating the data by the units of measure, with tons representing solid waste and barrels representing liquid waste is a straightforward concept that holds steadily from year to year, making it a convenient metric to work with. Reducing the number of categories makes understanding other aspects of waste, such as transportation and disposal methods, less chaotic to talk about as well.

At the same time, it must be stated that from the point of view of data analytics of oil and gas waste, this level of detail is really an embarrassment of riches when compared to other states.  Places like Ohio and West Virginia only include a “water” column in their production data, with no mention of leftover fracking chemicals, drilling mud, tank sediments, pond liners, or other waste streams.  Pennsylvania’s detailed reporting makes meaningful public analysis possible, and highlights the need for residents living in other states to demand similar levels of transparency from their own regulators.  

Conventional vs. Unconventional Sources

Pennsylvania classifies oil and gas wells as either conventional or unconventional.  While both types of wells are usually fracked, unconventional wells use dramatically more fluid – while a conventional well might use tens of thousands of gallons of water per well, an unconventional operation frequently will use tens of millions of gallons per well.  

On the production side of the equation, FracTracker quantified the outsized nature of Pennsylvania’s unconventional wells.  With around 14.6% of the total inventory, those wells contributed more than 99% of the state’s gas and condensate totals, and about 14.5% of the state’s oil, roughly proportional in that last category to the number of wells it represents.  Let’s see how the numbers stack up for waste.

CategoryWell CountLiquid (Barrels)Liquid per Well (Barrels)Percent LiquidSolid (Tons)Solid per Well (Tons)Percent Solid
Conventional23,6621,016,05942.91.4%1,2630.10.2%
Unconventional12,81671,599,3085,586.798.6%823,94664.399.8%
All Wells36,47972,615,3671,990.6100.0%825,20922.6100.0%
Table 2: 2025 Conventional vs. unconventional waste totals for Pennsylvania.  Waste data was downloaded from Pennsylvania DEP on June 16, 2026.

We can see that unconventional wells are once again in the driver’s seat for Pennsylvania’s waste stream, accounting for 98.6% of the state’s liquid waste by volume and 99.8% of the solid waste by mass.  This certainly makes sense, given the immense scale of the unconventional operations, as discussed above.  Additionally, most of the new drilling activity is unconventional, and one would expect increased waste streams with newer wells, including higher volumes of waste fluids to accompany the higher production levels, as well as the presence of drill cuttings.  

Because of these variables, it’s worth taking the per well values on Table 2 with a splash of brine, especially on the solids side —older wells won’t contribute any drill cuttings, for example.  But the mean values still give a sense of the differing scales of conventional and unconventional wells.  Conventional wells average 42.9 barrels of liquid waste and 0.1 tons of solid waste per year, while their unconventional counterparts average 5,587 barrels and 64.3 tons

Nonreporting Conventional Wells

Another eye-opening item on Table 2 is that it only includes data from 23,662 conventional wells.  As a point of comparison, the production report from the same time period and subset includes data from 79,836 wells, or almost 3.4 times as many.  This situation is worth a closer look.

CategoryProduction Report – All WellsProduction Report – Wells Reporting ProductionWaste Report – All WellsWaste Report – Wells Reporting WasteDifference (P-W: All Wells)Difference (P-W: Reporting Production or Waste)
Conventional79,83671,74323,66223,19856,17448,545
Unconventional13,69112,70912,81612,801875-92
All Wells93,52784,45236,47835,99957,04948,453
Table 3: Counts of wells appearing on the Pennsylvania production and waste reports for 2025. Production data was downloaded from DEP on March 21, 2026 and waste data was downloaded on June 16, 2026. Well counts are determined by the number of unique API permit numbers present on aggregated reports for the calendar year.

While there were 56,174 fewer conventional wells listed on the waste report than were on the production report for 2025, a little more nuance is merited here.  Operators sometimes have reasons for not producing (it could be shut-in, an injection well, etc.), so it is also worth looking at the number of wells that report any non-zero values on these reports.  There are still about 3.1 times as many conventional wells on the production report than the waste report for this variable, for an overall difference of 48,545 wells.

Note that this waste reporting phenomenon does not seem to be an issue with unconventional wells.  Our data actually show 92 more wells on the unconventional waste reports than on the production reports in instances where non-zero values are counted.  This is likely explained by the fact that the download date of our waste data is almost three months after when the production data was obtained, and DEP does accommodate stragglers in these reports.  

To our mind, the sharp contrast between the percentage of conventional and unconventional wells that submit data to the waste reports requires some sort of explanation.  In fact, O&G wells are known to frequently “water out,” a phenomenon where the ratio of waste fluids to hydrocarbons increases over time.  Authors of a 2024 publication on the topic looked at data from more than 153,000 wells in 18 different plays.  This didn’t include data from Pennsylvania, however, noting:

Because of apparent widespread irregularities with water production data from Pennsylvania, we did not include the Marcellus Formation in our analyses.

Conventional operators not reporting data to DEP is not a new problem.  In late 2022, DEP released a report detailing some of the compliance issues with operators of conventional wells, specifically calling out failures to submit reports for waste as one of the common themes.  

Over the past five years, DEP’s OOGM has identified significant non-compliance with laws and regulations in the conventional oil and gas industry, particularly regarding improper abandonment of oil and gas wells, as well as reporting requirements for hydrocarbon and waste production and mechanical integrity assessments 

Governor’s Lapsing Statement Report, December 29, 2022

However, on Table 3 (page 8) of that report which shows the top violations for conventional wells between 2017 and 2021, you can see that there were 1,827 administrative violations issued for failure to report annual production or status reports, and 722 more were issued a similar violation with slightly different wording, most likely representing an adjustment to the phrasing over the five-year period.  However, we don’t see the lack of waste reporting on this top 10 list.

It turns out that there is a good reason for this.  While operators need to report production or explain their lack of reporting, the same is not true of waste reporting.  When I asked about the tens of thousands of fewer wells on the waste report in an email correspondence, DEP Mineral Resources Program Specialist Paul Howard explained the discrepancy:

A comment is required when production is not reported, but a comment is not required when only production is reported and no waste. To identify a violation, there would need to be some other indication that waste was generated but not reported.

Paul Howard, Mineral Resources Program Specialist, Pennsylvania DEP

So while not reporting production or explaining non-production with a comment is a violation, the same is not true of waste.  Without applying the same reporting standard in an industry where non-compliance is already rampant, it seems like DEP would need to be extraordinarily lucky to stumble across these “other indications” of unreported waste generation.  

Brine Spreading

One way DEP might be able to find omissions in waste reporting is by taking a closer look at waste disposal methods, particularly brine spreading.  In 2024 testimony before the Pennsylvania House Environmental Resources & Energy Committee, DEP explained that the department used to allow the practice of spreading oil and gas liquid waste on roadways for dust suppression and de-icing, but banned the practice for waste from unconventional wells in 2016. With respect to waste from conventional wells, the picture is less clear. DEP has supported a statutory ban of road-spreading brine from conventional wells and claims it will not authorize the practice in the face of concerns that contaminants will reach the waters of the Commonwealth. Whether the practice is actually illegal, however, remains untested.

In DEP’s discussion of the issue, the language reads as both clunky and purposeful.  For example, in the opening paragraph, the testimony reads: 

As noted below, road spreading of brine is currently not an authorized practice in Pennsylvania and DEP has the authority to take enforcement action in instances where it becomes aware of spreading that violates the laws or regulations that DEP implements.

Pennsylvania DEP testimony, House Environmental Resources & Energy Committee, 2024

A non-authorized practice is not the same as a banned practice. There may be no legal mechanism by which DEP will authorize brine spreading, but that does not mean that DEP considers the practice to be illegal. Other than the proximity of the words, there is no actual indication that the enforcement actions for violations actually apply in this situation.

A bit later, the testimony states:

In 2017, the DEP discontinued the practice of authorizing brine use for dust suppression purposes under the guidance document. Since that time, the DEP has not authorized the use of brine as a dust suppressant under the 1998 guidance document or the Commonwealth’s Oil and Gas Act. 

Pennsylvania DEP testimony, House Environmental Resources & Energy Committee, 2024

Once again, we have very specific language where the Department asserts that it “discontinued the practice of authorizing” the use of this waste, but here, it mentions only dust suppression, and omits any reference to brine spreading for deicing purposes.

Also discussed is the issue of coproduct determination, which is essentially a process that would indicate that an apparent waste product is no longer considered to be waste:

A coproduct determination, which shall be made in accordance with § 287.8 (relating to coproduct determinations), only applies to materials that will be applied to the land or used to produce products that are applied to the land….A material meeting these requirements does not require a waste permit for the use of the material, but the laws and regulations regarding the protection of water quality still apply to its use.

Pennsylvania DEP testimony, House Environmental Resources & Energy Committee, 2024

This could be interpreted as a sizable loophole in the waste reporting requirements. Would a determination that brine is a coproduct (and therefore not a waste product at all) apply retroactively to the point of production, exempting the operators of 48,545 conventional wells from reporting their waste totals, so long as it was used in such a manner?

Interestingly, the testimony goes on to state that DEP reached out to each of the 26 operators who reported disposing of waste via brine spreading on Pennsylvania roads in 2021.  Two of these said that brine spreading was reported in error, 13 said that they would stop the practice, “Two operators responded with information that did not constitute a valid coproduct determination,” and nine more simply didn’t reply.  

In 2026, despite DEP’s testimony of “discontinued the practice of authorizing” brine spreading, we hear continued reports of the ongoing use of the practice. Perhaps the real lesson learned by operators was simply not to report such usage, so as not to be hassled by the Department. 

Destination and Disposal

Oil and gas development generates both liquid and solid wastes that must ultimately be reused, processed or disposed of. Liquid waste such as produced water may be reused in the development or hydraulic fracturing of other wells, sent to facilities for processing or treatment, or disposed of in underground injection wells. Solid wastes, including drilling wastes, may be sent to processing or permitted disposal facilities such as landfills. The waste reports are intended to track these movements from the well where the waste was generated to the destination and management method reported by the operator.  

Disposal MethodLiquids (Bbl)Solids (Tons)
Centralized Waste Treatment Facility (NPDES Discharge)18,8730
Centralized Treatment Plant (for Recycling)909,49819
Injection Disposal Well4,479,5836,388
Landfill137697,590
On-Site Encapsulation2
On-Site Pit123
Public Sewage Treatment Plant207,698909
Residual Waste Processing Facility22,782,03181,160
Residual Waste Transfer Facility1,5394,455
Reuse (at Well Pad)31,024,14521,846
Reuse at a Conventional Well Site in Pennsylvania126,502
Reuse at a Well Pad Outside Pennsylvania2,819,0982,496
Reuse Other than Road Spreading22,505135
Road Spreading285
Storage Pending Disposal or Reuse7,753,1409,817
Surface Impoundment2,470,206393
Total Result72,615,367825,209
Table 4: Oil and gas waste disposal methods as reported by Pennsylvania operators in 2025. Based on data downloaded from Pennsylvania DEP on June 16, 2026.

As established above in the Nonreporting Conventional Wells section, missing data is a part of the story.  Acknowledging that, this section is focused on what is actually disclosed by the various operators, who reported sending the waste from Pennsylvania’s O&G wells to 532 destinations in seven states. 

Some of these destinations are not a single location.  For example, 126,387 barrels of waste was sent to a destination entitled, “Conventional wells report does not require reuse location,” noting another distinction between conventional and unconventional waste requirements. Destination descriptions for waste sent to out of state wells for the purpose of reuse are similarly vague, such as the 27,498 barrels destined for “Reuse at Ohio well pad” or the 346 barrels sent for “Reuse at Montana well pad.”  

The report also can’t answer why an operator called “Loan Asset Issuer LLC Series 2021 NG-1” would choose to send a couple of tanker trucks worth of produced fluid from a well called “Consol WFN6HHS” in West Finley Township, Washington County more than 1,500 miles for reuse at a Montana well pad.  We just know that it happened, according to the operator’s disclosure.

Uncovering every curiosity in the waste reports would be like describing every piece of hay in a haystack, so at some point, it’s useful to step back and look at the overall trends.  For this, we invite you to take a look at the waste map linked above, which includes aggregated solid and liquid waste totals for receiving facilities that we were able to map.  This was quite a process as well, because there are three different ways that the operators can indicate the location of the receiving location, and even so, there are widespread reliability issues.  

For example, there are data columns for well pad latitude and longitude for when operators reuse the waste at a different well pad, but instead they often put the location of the well pad that the waste originated from.  There is a different set of coordinates for other waste facilities, or they can use addresses.  Sometimes, the addresses are clearly corporate offices, and sometimes, none of these are filled out.  Because of this, we cross-referenced with other sources, including DEP’s well pad and waste facilities reports, and double checking these using Google Maps for plausibility.  For the aggregated sites such as “Reuse at Ohio well pad,” we simply had to pick a location.  

Because of this confusion, we have categorized these receiving facilities based on our overall confidence of the location’s accuracy, with purple square icons indicating high confidence, where we believe we have the correct facility location, brown showing medium confidence, where location accuracy issues are thought to be at the county level or less or else some inconsistencies were noted, such as the use of well pad ID numbers that weren’t found on the well pad report, and red showing low confidence, with location uncertainty greater than the county level.  That said, our tools for making these assessments are imperfect, so if you would notice any errors, we would very much appreciate your feedback.

Another way to understand the flow of waste is to visualize them through Sankey charts.  Here, we have separate charts for waste reported in tons and barrels.  Within each one, we include all of the specific waste types that contribute to the total, the states that the waste was sent to, as well as the disposal method.

Figure 1: Chart showing waste type, receiving destination, and disposal method of solid waste generated in Pennsylvania in 2025. Waste data for this chart was downloaded from Pennsylvania DEP on June 16, 2026.

Mousing over any part of this chart gives more information about what we are seeing. On the left half of the map, the proportional-width strands are color coded to indicate the state they they are destined for, with waste staying in Pennsylvania shown in blue, Ohio-bound waste in orange, and waste headed for sites in West Virginia in green, with other locations shown in grey.  On the right side, the strands reorganize to indicate the disposal method indicated by the operators.

On the top left, we see that drill cuttings are the real driver of solid waste, accounting for about 707,000 out of 825,000 tons, almost 86% of the total.  Of this, about 589,000 tons (83%) stayed in Pennsylvania, with around 114,000 tons (16%) headed to Ohio and 3,700 tons (0.5%) to West Virginia.  These proportions vary by the specific category.  For example, the Mountain State does take larger proportions of produced fluids that were reported in tons, accepting around 15,000 tons of almost 55,000 tons (28%) in that category.

Let’s take a look at the flow of the liquid waste.

Figure 2: Chart showing waste type, receiving destination, and disposal method of liquid waste generated in Pennsylvania in 2025. Waste data for this chart was downloaded from Pennsylvania DEP on June 16, 2026.

Operators reported nearly 70.3 million barrels of produced water, representing almost 97% of all waste reported in barrels.  About 63.3 million barrels of the produced water stayed in-state, or about 90%.  For all liquid waste, 65.4 out of 72.6 million barrels stayed in the Keystone State, also about 90% of that total.

If we take disposal methods into account, we can see some more nuance.  For example, a little under 4.5 million barrels (6%) of all liquid waste is reported going to injection wells for disposal.  However, Pennsylvania does not have very many injection wells compared to our neighbors, so in this subcategory, Ohio actually accepts three times the amount of waste as Pennsylvania does, with around 3.4 million barrels going to the Buckeye State compared to 1.1 million barrels staying in Pennsylvania, as was recently pointed out in the New York Times using FracTracker analysis.  Less than 4,200 barrels (0.09%) was sent to West Virginia’s injection wells, and about 17,000 barrels were sent to an injection well where the state was not indicated.  Some further research on that last item shows that the injection well in question, CNR East Warrent 3131 T10, is an enhanced oil recovery injection well operated by Pennhills Resources in McKean County, Pennsylvania.

It is important to note that we don’t have comparable data from other states to quantify the amount of waste that might be headed to Pennsylvania, as Ohio and West Virginia do not have waste reports with the destination data that the Pennsylvania report provides.  The general assumption is that since Pennsylvania is the largest producer of the three states with almost 7.7 trillion cubic feet (Tcf) of gas compared to 3.6 Tcf in West Virginia and 2.1 Tcf in Ohio, that it generates more waste and furthermore, it would seem plausible that the net flow of the subset of waste that crosses state lines travels from Pennsylvania to its neighbors.  Without data showing the destination of Ohio and West Virginia, however, that remains little more than a hunch.

Another thing to point out is that some of the disposal methods don’t really seem like endpoints in the story of the waste, but it is where we lose track of it from these oil and gas waste reports.  For example, 7.75 million barrels of liquids are sent to “storage pending disposal or reuse.”  That amounts to almost 11% of the total volume of liquid waste, and almost 3.3 million barrels more than waste sent to injection wells.  Almost 2.5 million barrels, more than 3% of the total, were sent to surface impoundments, but it seems unlikely that the waste would remain there in perpetuity.  And while residual waste processing facilities sounds like a reasonable destination for the 22.8 million barrels (31%) of liquid waste and 81,000 tons (10%) of solid waste, these facilities have their own waste streams and impacts, and while the overall contaminant load may originate from oil and gas wells, from the point of view of DEP’s O&G waste report, it is a sort of black hole.  Once the waste trucks pass the gates of these facilities (or the “event horizon” in our metaphor), we lose track of it forever as oil and gas waste.  For that matter, even the 698,000 tons of solid waste sent to landfills isn’t quite an endpoint, either, as some of the contaminants including radioactive materials and heavy metals percolate through the landfill to produce leachate every time it rains, presenting yet another waste mitigation conundrum.  

What Contaminants are in the Waste?  

Oil and gas waste often contains radioactive, carcinogenic and other highly hazardous materials at levels far exceeding guidelines for human safety. Yet, thanks to an industry loophole, Pennsylvania O&G waste is defined as a kind of residual waste, which is supposed to represent nonhazardous industrial waste. The nonhazardous status traces back to the 1980 Bentsen Amendment to the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA), which exempted oil and gas waste from Subtitle C, the portion of RCRA that regulates hazardous waste. While New York has taken action to close this loophole in their state law and allow hazardous waste standards to be applied to O&G waste streams, Pennsylvania has not.

Of course, just because the waste is defined residual and not hazardous waste doesn’t mean that the waste is safe to be around.  Pennsylvania, to its credit, “requires residual waste generators to submit information annually to the Department, for every waste stream they produce.”  This is achieved through the submission of Form 26R, a form that requires detailed chemical analysis of waste every five years. The rules for this disclosure are as follows:

  • Generators of all residual waste streams, including O&G operators, are required to complete Form 26R for each waste stream to the facility where the waste is processed or disposed
  • This must be accompanied by a detailed chemical analysis for each waste stream.  The law states three different frequencies of this auxiliary report
    • Annual is the default standard
    • Operators can declare that the chemical analysis remains approximately the same and test every five years instead
    • The chemical analysis waiver can be extended beyond the five-year window for certain categories of waste

The generator is required to submit a copy of Form 26R for each waste stream to the solid waste management facility where the waste is sent for processing or disposal. After initial submission of a detailed chemical analysis for a waste stream, the waste generator may select to certify annually by providing sufficient documentation that the chemical and physical characteristics of the waste and the processes by which the waste was generated have not changed from the previous year submission, in lieu of annually performing the chemical analysis. The waste will have to be fully characterized every five (5) years even if no changes in the process generating the waste or the characteristics in the waste have occurred. For the categories of residual wastes that are covered in Section D of Form U, the chemical analysis waiver can be extended beyond the five-year period as long as there are no changes in the manufacturing process or ingredients that may result in changes to the waste characterization or chemical composition of the waste.

While oil and gas operators have been required to submit this form, the information has not been broadly available to the public until a recent concerted effort by Earthjustice, Ohio Valley Allies, WildEarth Guardians and FracTracker. On behalf of Ohio Valley Allies, Earthjustice submitted a Right-to-Know Law request for all O&G 26R reports since 2015 for unconventional wells, a massive amount of previously hard to access data about the chemical composition of PA’s oil and gas waste. Since many of these reports had not been digitized, Jill Hunkler of Ohio Valley Allies, Melissa Troutman of WildEarth Guardians, and others went to great lengths and spent several days scanning roughly 400,000 pages. Gary Allison, a consultant for FracTracker, subsequently assembled and began a preliminary analysis of the released Form 26R reports. This collaborative effort supplied key data for a recent New York Times investigation, which found that four injection wells near Marietta, Ohio, accepted wastewater from Pennsylvania fracking sites reporting median radium-226 levels 428 to 1,800 times EPA’s drinking-water standard. 

At the same time, FracTracker’s review of these released 26R reports suggests that these 400,000 pages didn’t contain every chemical analysis that would be expected under the five-year reporting schedule. Section D of Form U allows the chemical-analysis waiver to be extended for certain categories of residual waste, but it does not clearly state whether oil and gas waste qualifies for such an extension. It therefore remains unclear whether the apparent gaps reflect DEP not producing every responsive record, operators failing to file required reports, or the use of extended waivers and other interpretations of the reporting requirements. Despite these limitations, the 26R reports contain chemical analyses that document very high concentrations of hazardous contaminants in some oil and gas waste streams.  

Below are two examples of these chemical analysis reports, one for drill cuttings and the other for wastewater.  

Page 17 of the Eurofins laboratory analysis for Alexander BRA pad drill cuttings, showing 1,2,4-Trimethylbenzene at 22.1 mg/Kg.
Figure 3: Form 26R and Eurofins laboratory analysis for drill cuttings from the Alexander Bra Pad, Bradford County. The 26R report lists 3,156.79 tons of drill cuttings sent to five facilities in three states; the Client Sample Results begin on PDF page 17. View the full report (PDF).

This document starts with the 26R report.  In Section A on the first page, we can see that this waste sample is from the Alexander Bra Pad, a well operated by Chesapeake in Bradford County.  In Section B, we can see that the operator is reporting 3,156.79 tons of drill cuttings.  In Section C on pages 2-3, we can see that portions of this waste were sent to Alliance Landfill in Lackawana County, Phoenix Resources in Tioga County, Casella in Chemung County, New York, Tunnel Hill Reclamation in Perry County, Ohio, and NTSWA Landfill #2 in Bradford County.  

It’s a long document, so we are going to skip all the way down to the Client Sample Results section showing the chemical analysis performed by Eurofins TestAmerica, which is on PDF pages 17-20, or pages 13-16 of the lab report itself.  This lab formats non-detected analytes in black text and with an “ND” in the results column.  Analytes at detectable limits are shown in blue, with the Result being paired with the item in the Unit column.  The first one that we come across is 1,2,4-Trimethylbenzene, which is present at 22.1 milligrams per kilogram (mg/kg, and the next detected analyte is Ethylbenzene, at 3.3 mg/kg.  

If you are not a chemist and would like to understand more about the nature of these chemicals, you can look many of them up on the Open-FF Chemical Hazard Aggregator.  Gary Allison, Open-FF Founder and FracTracker Consultant, designed this tool to describe the relative hazards of chemicals that were reported as components of the injection fluid to FracFocus, the industry’s chemical disclosure registry that is required by many states, including Pennsylvania.  For that trimethylbenzene isomer, for example, we can see that PubChem gives the following warnings:

Figure 4: PubChem warnings about the impacts of 1,2,4-Trimethylbenzene. Aggregated by Open-FF, including that the substance is potentially fatal if swallowed or inhaled.

Further down, we see that the sample also contains 82,200 mg/Kg of diesel range organics and 40.9 milligrams per liter (mg/L) of strontium, another chemical tied to significant health concerns.  EPA considers strontium levels under 4 mg/L to be safe for consumption throughout one’s lifetime (see page 17).

No radiological analyses were performed on this drill cuttings sample, so let’s pivot to the wastewater sample, where such tests were conducted.

Page 17 of the Eurofins laboratory analysis, listing chloride at 117,000 mg/L, barium at 16,100 mg/L, calcium at 54,500 mg/L and strontium at 5,580 mg/L.
Figure 5: Eurofins laboratory analysis of wastewater from the DGSM Bra well pad, Bradford County. Page 17 of 38 is shown: chloride at 117,000 mg/L, barium at 16,100 mg/L, calcium at 54,500 mg/L and strontium at 5,580 mg/L. View the full report (PDF).

As with the drill cuttings sample, this analysis was conducted by Eurofins for a Chesapeake well.  In this case, we don’t have the associated 26R report, but there is a chain of custody form on page 35 that indicates this sample is associated with the DGSM Bra well pad, another well pad in Bradford County.  The Client Sample Results are on pages 17-18, and include a contaminant profile that is different from the drill cuttings sample, including:

  • Chlorides – 117,000 mg/L.  For reference, sea water typically has chlorides around 19,000 mg/L, making this sample six times saltier.
  • Strontium – 5,580 mg/L.  This is 1,395 times the lifetime standard of 4 mg/L, mentioned above
  • Barium – 16,100 mg/L.  This is 8,050 times the legal limit for drinking water
  • Calcium – 54,500 mg/L.  The US Geological Survey considers hard water to be 121 mg/L or above of combined calcium and magnesium.  Magnesium was a non-detect (based on a 10,000 mg/L reporting limit), but the calcium values certainly explain why operators inject anti-scaling agents downhole, as that is enough to gum up any pipe.
  • Radium-226 – 8,570 picocuries per liter (pCi/L) – Radium is a dangerous radioactive element.  This isotope decays into Radon-222 by ejecting an alpha particle. 
  • Radium-228 – 1,320 pCi/L.  Another dangerous radium isotope.  The legal drinking water limit for the two combined isotopes of radium is 5 pCi/L (see page 17), making this sample 1,978 times this amount.  

Browsing through the reports, note that this is just a sampling of the chemicals of interest.  Even though we are just looking at a few examples of the 26R reports and their associated lab reports, we can already see that there are enormous waste quantities with highly concentrated contaminant loads being sent to locations throughout Pennsylvania and neighboring states.  In that first document, we see drill cuttings sent from one well pad to five destinations in three different states.  In the second, the 26R report became disassociated, but the lab report shows us chemicals of concern in very high quantities that have the potential to impact neighbors and the environment of the sites where this waste is brought to the surface, handled, transferred, and disposed of.   

Conclusion

The Pennsylvania DEP’s oil and gas waste report provides quite a bit of insight into the waste streams created by the nation’s second largest gas producer.  We know that operators of the state’s oil and gas waste wells reported around 72.6 million barrels of liquid waste and 825,000 tons of solid waste.  We know the state’s unconventional wells, despite representing less than 15% of the total wells, account for nearly 99% of liquids and almost 100% of solid waste on the report.  We know that about 97% of all liquid waste is categorized as produced fluids, which in recent years includes both brine and flowback fluids.  Similarly, almost 86% of solid waste on the report is drill cuttings.  We know that while some of the waste is sent as far away as Montana or Arkansas, over 90% of the liquids and 81% of the solids on the report stay in-state.  

We also know a significant amount about what’s in the waste, making it clear that this waste can pose a serious threat to public health. Our review of the laboratory reports submitted as part of 26R forms document some waste streams containing striking concentrations of chloride, barium, strontium, petroleum compounds, and radioactive radium. One wastewater sample, for example, contained a combined 9,890 picocuries per liter of radium-226 and radium-228—nearly 2,000 times EPA’s drinking-water limit. 

And yet, digging through the data to find these answers have created just as many questions.  We don’t know why there are 48,545 wells that report some amount of oil and gas production but zero waste generation.  Despite reports of it occurring, we can’t quantify the practice of road spreading brine for dust suppression or de-icing on Pennsylvania roads.  We don’t know the volumes of waste coming into Pennsylvania from neighboring states, or why a Pennsylvania operator would pay to have several tanker trucks worth of drilling waste shipped all the way to Montana.  We don’t know the exact location of some of the receiving facilities, nor do we know what happens to much of the waste beyond some of the temporary arrangements designated on the report.  We also don’t have chemical lab analyses for all of the wells

As a reminder, around 1 in 4 Pennsylvanians rely on private well water for their drinking source.  The facilities that extract, store, and process this waste can’t remove the contaminant load with a flick of the wrist, and there really isn’t a great place for any of it, short of keeping it in situ.  Many of the residents that bring up concerns about pollution from O&G waste are worried about contamination of their water supplies and the potential for permanent health effects.  If we return to that imagery of two Empire State Buildings worth of solid waste, and of watching the water flow over Niagara Falls for 67 minutes, we do so with the knowledge that this waste created in Pennsylvania every year is anything but benign.  And while RCRA and DEP may sanitize the language by categorizing this waste “residual” instead of “hazardous”, that does nothing to sanitize the water itself.

Stay informedFracTracker Newsletter
Support our work

FracTracker Alliance helps communicate the risks of oil and gas and petrochemical development to advance just energy alternatives that protect public health, natural resources, and the climate.

By contributing to FracTracker, you are helping to make tangible changes, such as decreasing the number of oil and gas wells in the US, protecting the public from toxic and radioactive chemicals, and stopping petrochemical expansion into vulnerable communities.

Your donations help fund the sourcing and analysis of new data so that we can keep you informed and continually update our resources.

Please donate to FracTracker today as a way to advocate for clean water, clean air, and healthy communities.

Donate now
Aerial view of red brine haulers traveling on rural roads near homes in Moundsville, West Virginia.

PA DEP Approves Unusual “Mineral Brine” Well in Erie County, Raising Concerns About New Regulatory Loophole

Media Advisory: PA DEP Approves Unusual “Mineral Brine” Well in Erie County, Raising Concerns About New Regulatory Loophole. FracTracker appeals permit, citing unresolved questions about testing and sale of highly saline subsurface water that can contain radium, metals, and other contaminants

Pennsylvania Oil and Gas Industry Trends: Drilled Wells, Violations, Production, and Waste

This article looks at trends in the oil and gas industry in Pennsylvania, including the number of drilled wells, violations that have been issued, oil and gas production, and waste generation. We also point out examples of how data limitations make it challenging to answer frequently asked questions.

Empowering Colorado Communities: The Importance of the Community Right to Know Act

Communities in Colorado should be immediately informed of oil and gas spills that increase their health risks. Our analysis shows why public health alerts are particularly important for communities located near extraction operations.

Where Do We Cross the Line: From Public Service to Public Threat

As industry expands within the primarily residential and agricultural community of Eaton Township, Ohio, community members wonder if the EPA and local government are doing enough to protect human health and the environment.

East Palestine Warning: The Growing Threat From Hazardous Waste Storage

Is the gradual increase in hazardous waste storage and incineration expansion in Eaton Township, Ohio, fueling a preventable future disaster?

Photo by David Nix 2015

How Spills, Holes, and Cracks Release Fracking Chemicals Into the Environment

FracTracker dives into how toxic fracking chemicals and waste products enter our environment through accidents, spills, and equipment failures, and the impact on Pennsylvania communities.

East Palestine Train Derailment Waste: Community Impacts

As of March 10, 2023, 152,796 tons of liquid waste and 2,980 tons of solid waste have been removed from the site of the train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio, to three injection wells and four hazardous waste disposal sites in Ohio, Michigan, Indiana, and Texas.